ACM Workshop on Negative Results in Network Measurements (NetNeg)
The workshop will take place at Room 505.
1:15 - 1:25 | Opening Remarks |
1:25 - 2:05 | Keynote: "False, Unknown, and the Scientific Value of Not Knowing" Speaker: Prof. Dr. Fabian E. Bustamante (Northwestern University) |
2:05 - 2:45 | Session 1 2:05 - 2:35 | Paper Presentation When the Crowd Doesn't Show Up: How Measurement Vantage Points Reveal (or Hide) Traffic Peaks During UEFA EURO 2024 Yasin Alhamwy (University of Kassel), Oliver Hohlfeld (University of Kassel) Idle Periods in Ookla Speed Tests on Embedded Devices: A Cross-Layer Investigation Ricky K. P. Mok (CAIDA/UC San Diego), Ben Kosters (Calvin University), Tanmay Nale (UC San Diego), Rocky K. C. Chang (Calvin University) Lessons from an (Unsuccessful?) IPv6 Amplification Honeypot Deployment Tiago Heinrich (Max Planck Institute for Informatics), Sebastian Kappes (Max Planck Institute for Informatics), Rafael Obelheiro (Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina (UDESC)) 2:35 - 2:45 | Paper Presenter Panel |
2:45 - 3:15 | Break |
3:15 - 3:50 | Keynote: "(When) the path to negative results is paved with good intentions" Speaker: Prof. Dr. Marwan Fayed (Cloudflare and University of St Andrews) |
3:50 - 4:20 | Session 2 3:50 - 4:10 | Paper Presentation Combo: Proactive Momentum and the Reactive Wall Ghazal Abdollahi (University of Utah), Hamid Asadi (University of Utah), Robert Ricci (University of Utah) Mind the Generalization Gap: Lessons from Reproducing Research on Machine Learning for Wireless Networks Lavesh Mangal (New York University), Fraida Fund (New York University), Shivendra Panwar (New York University) 4:10 - 4:20 | Paper Presenter Panel |
4:20 - 4:45 | Expert Panel: "Beyond Negative Results: What Our Network Measurements Reveal" Panelists: Prof. Dr. Fabian E. Bustamante (Northwestern University) Prof. Dr. Marwan Fayed (Cloudflare, and University of St Andrews) Dr. Vasileios Giotsas (Cloudflare) Assoc. Prof. Dr. Arpit Gupta (UC Santa Barbara) Dr. Loqman Salamatian (Columbia University) |
Network measurement research has traditionally favored work that advances the state-of-the-art, either through improved measurement techniques or new empirical insights. This approach has often translated into a focus on measurement techniques, sophisticated inference methods, and large-scale empirical studies expected to yield strong, positive conclusions. However, research efforts do not always produce statistically significant or practically meaningful results. Measurement campaigns can reveal biases in datasets, limitations in vantage point diversity, or inconsistencies in collected measurement data across different types of networks. Similarly, newly proposed inference methods may fail to generalize, or yield results that hold only under restrictive conditions.
The workshop aims to provide a venue for constructive discussion on lessons learned from studies in which methods, datasets or experimental designs did not yield the expected results.
The main topics of interest include (but are not limited to):
- Bias and limitations in the data collection
- Experiments that fail due to design flaws or system bottlenecks
- Unexpected or controversial results that challenge conventional expectations
- Experiments impacted by policy, compliance or ethical constraints
- Reproducibility challenges due to missing or incomplete datasets
- Insights from failed trials, preliminary verification efforts or optimizations
- Approaches and techniques applied to networking that fail to generalize
The workshop invites submissions that report and reflect negative results in network measurement studies. Submissions should focus on fundamental issues related to measurement approaches, methodology, underlying assumptions, rather than on non-fundamental issues such as implementation bugs or misconfigurations. Focusing on the critical parts of the experiment, the workshop aims to strengthen rigor, promote transparency and improve methodology practices in network measurement research.
We are looking for two types of submissions:
- Research papers of up to 6 pages, including all figures, tables, references, and appendices in two-column 10pt ACM format. Submissions must be original, unpublished work, and not under consideration at another conference or journal.
- Extended abstracts of up to 2 pages (excluding references), submitted in the same format as the workshop papers. We welcome submissions that showcase lessons learned from past or ongoing experiments that led to negative results.
NetNeg follows a double-blind reviewing process and submissions must be anonymized. Authors of accepted papers are expected to present their papers at the workshop.
Please submit your paper via https://netneg26.hotcrp.com.
| Submission deadline | May 20, 2026 |
|---|---|
| Acceptance notification | June 12, 2026 |
| Camera-ready deadline | June 20, 2026 |
| Workshop date | August 17, 2026 |
| General & Steering Committee Co-Chairs | Institution |
|---|---|
| Ioana Livadariu | Simula Metropolitan |
| Mattijs Jonker | University of Twente |
| Program Committee | Institution |
| Cristel Pelsser | UCLouvain |
| Gautam Akiwate | Stanford University |
| Georgios Smaragdakis | Delft University of Technology |
| Ioana Livadariu | Simula Metropolitan |
| Johannes Zirngibl | Max Planck Institute for Informatics |
| Loqman Salamatian | Columbia University |
| Mattijs Jonker | University of Twente |
| Oliver Gasser | IPinfo |
| Robert Beverly | San Diego State University |
| Stephen Strowes | Fastly |
| Vasileios Giotsas | Cloudflare |